Critical Approaches to Literature: A Brief Overview
Anthropological |
Archetypal |
Biographical |
Narratological |
New Criticism |
(New) Historicism |
Post-Structuralism |
Psychoanalytic |
Reader-Response |
Semiotics |
Social |
Structuralism |
|
Archetypes are figures or patterns recurring in works of the imagination, and can be divided into three categories. Archetypal characters include (but are not limited to): the hero, the villain, the outcast, the femme fatale, and the star-crossed lovers. Archetypal situations include (but are not limited to): the quest, the journal, death and rebirth, and the task. Archetypal symbols and associations include polarities: light/dark, water/desert, height/depth, spring/winter. It is important to note two things. First, works may contain multiple archetypes. Second, not everything is an archetype. A balance between these two extremes can be very difficult to achieve. Looking for recurring patterns within a piece or within a collection of related stories can be useful in using this approach. For further reading: Northrop Frye's The Educated Imagination and Anatomy of Criticism.
Biographical criticism has two weaknesses that should be avoided. First, avoid equating the work's content with the author's life (or the character with the author); they are not necessarily the same. Second, avoid less-than-credible sources of information, particularly works that tend to be highly speculative or controversial unless verified by several sources. (Some of the recent biographies on Thomas Jefferson might serve as an example of this pitfall.) For further reading: Charles Dickens: A Critical Introduction by K. J. Fielding; Henry James: His Life and Writings by F. W. Duppee; and The Far Side of Paradise: A Biography of F. Scott Fitzgerald by Arthur Mizener.
For further reading: The New Criticism by John Crow Ransom.
New Historicism is concerned with relating the idea of a text to other key concepts: culture, discourse, ideology, the self, and history. New Historicists examine intersections of text, reader, and history and with a special emphasis on literature as a cultural text. New Historicists also examine the relationship of literature to the power structures of society. Historical research might include Biography (see above), reception studies, influence studies, or even a technological approach to the medium (filmmaking, printing, the music industry, computers and the WWW). It has also been utilized with Reader-Response criticism (see below). You might ask, "How does the text embody a history of its time? Is this text a useful historical document?" For further reading: Columbia Literary History of the United States, edited by Emory Elliot, and The Literary History of England, edited by Albert C. Baugh.
For further reading: From the New Criticism to Deconstruction by Art Berman and Deconstruction: Theory and Practice by Christopher Norris.
Three ideas found in the work of Sigmund Freud are particularly useful: the dominance of the unconscious mind over the conscious, the expression of the unconscious mind through symbols (often in dreams), and sexuality as a powerful force for motivating human behavior. Psychoanalytic criticism can be applied to either the author/text relationship or to the reader/text relationship. You might ask, "How is this text use or represent the unconscious mind: of the author, the characters, the reader?" For further reading: Literature and Psychoanalysis, edited by Edith Kurzweil and William Phillips, and The Purloined Poe: Lacan, Derrida and Psychoanalytic Reading, edited by John P. Muller and William J. Richardson.
For further reading: The Reader in the Text: Essays on Audience and Interpretation ,edited by Susan R. Suleiman and Inge Crossman, and Is There a Text in This Class? The Authority of Interpretive Communities by Stanley Fish.
Marxism is concerned with labor practices, class theories, and economics, especially as concerned with the struggles of the poor and oppressed. A Marxist might ask, "How are classes stratified/defined in this text? Does this text reflect an economic ideology? What is the attitude toward labor furthered by this text?" For further reading: Marx, Engels, and the Poets: Origins of Marxist Literary Criticism by Peter Demetz and Marxism and Literary Criticism by Terry Eagleton. Feminist Criticism examine works by and about women. Gender Criticism evolved out of feminism to address issues of masculinity/femininity as binaries, sexual orientation, hetereosexism, and differences in sexes. Both are political activities concerned with fair representation and treatment of people. A critcic using Feminist Studies or Gender Studies (sometimes also known as Queer Studies) might ask, "How is gender constructed or deconstructed in this text? Is the view of the text gendered or sexist?" For further reading: The New Feminist Criticism: Essays on Women, Literature, and Theory, edited by Elaine Showalter, and The Gay and Lesbian Studies Reader, edited by Henry Avelove, et al. A Green Critic might ask, "Of what priority is conservation in this text? What is the relationship between humankind and Nature?"
For further reading: Semiotic and Structural Analyses of Fiction: An Introduction and a Survey of Applications by Leonard Orr; Structuralism in Literature: An Introduction by Robert Scholes; and The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts by Umberto Eco. |